Showing posts with label Keynes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Keynes. Show all posts

Monday, May 7, 2012

Anti-Austerity in Europe

I watched the outcome of the French election with considerable interest. It seems that anti-austerity is becoming a major force in Europe. Even more interesting is the collapse of the will for austerity in Greece.

It is a quite fascinating situation, which is also quite alarming. It is fascinating as the 'Krugmanesque' vision of economics may finally be put to the test. That is, it seems that it may now be the case that the borrow and spend spigots will open for already 'in trouble' economies. As regular readers will know, I do not deny that borrow and spend will indeed create employment. After all, it is not difficult to spend somebody else's wealth on make-work activity or paying for activities that would otherwise not be affordable. I do not deny that this will create more tax revenue. If more people are working, and more are spending, then indeed this will indeed create the activity in the economy that will garner greater tax revenue. Likewise, this increased activity will appear to either slow economic shrinkage, stabilise, or even grow an economy.

The problem is that it is very, very easy to spend the wealth of others in generating activity. The problem is that this borrowed wealth will eventually need to be returned to the lender. This in turn generates the problem that, if people doubt the borrower's ability to repay, then they will not lend. The question then arises as to whom, exactly, these want to be borrowers might actually borrow from. It is all very well for people to march on the streets and demand an end to austerity, but they are demanding that governments spend money that they do not have. However much these marching/protesting individuals and their political leaders demand borrow and spend, they have a problem. The problem is simple. They simply do not, within their own country, create the wealth that they desire. That is why they must borrow.

The wealth that is desired by the protesters and their political leaders only exists external to their own economy. It is not theirs, and short of going to war, they can only access this pool of wealth if the holders of the wealth choose to allow access to it. No amount of protest, political rhetoric, demands, tantrums and so forth, will change this.

Of course, there is always the possibility of raising taxation in a country to pay for all of the government spending. It is always possible to squeeze the pips out of the wealthy. Or at least, as long as the wealthy hang around to be squeezed. However, the term capital flight is not abstract; there comes a point at which people feel that the redistribution of their wealth to others is unacceptable, and they will choose to remove their wealth to a place where such a redistribution will not take place.

Even if accepting that the wealthy can be squeezed, the 'in trouble' economies will have to squeeze very hard  to make up for the loss of borrowed wealth from external sources. And that is the problem; even if increasing taxation for the wealthy, will governments be able to manage without the borrowing of external wealth to pay for all of their reinstated/increased spending programmes? I mean really; can this do the trick? I very much doubt it. 

The plans of the anti-austerity movement are quite remarkable. They are remarkable in that they assume that there is some hidden source of wealth that is the right of their country. They do not have, or produce, this wealth themselves, but are apparently entitled to it. If the anti-austerity movement wins out, we will be able to see whether the Krugman approach actually really works in practice. I read recently that Krugman's view is influencing political leaders in Europe; that his proposed remedies are believed to be the solution.

Of course, there is nothing to say that some of the 'in-trouble' economies might not borrow a bit longer. For a while at least, the Krugman solution may appear to work, and encourage others to speak out/act against austerity.The success of anti-austerity will, if this takes place, be trumpeted as a solution - at least up to the point that the lenders of wealth lose all confidence. As an analogy, think of the Jurassic Park films; there is a sequence in which the lead character says something along the lines of; 'That's how it always starts, with the oohs and aahs, but then the biting and the eating starts'.

So, if the anti-austerity movement wins for a while, those in favour of the movement will sound out their 'oohs and aahs', but when all confidence is lost, the picture will change dramatically. It is quite possible that we are about to witness a real world economic experiment, in which the theories of individuals such as Krugman will finally be tested. They believe that wealth can simply appear by borrow and spend/tax and spend. They believe this will create a virtuous cycle that will fix economies.

I, on the other hand, believe that wealth is, in the end, created by creating a framework in which individual endeavour creates real wealth. This individual endeavour, whether from a bricklayer or a the CEO of a multinational, is the real source of wealth creation. They make products and services that people want, and can pay for the goods and services as a result of their own individual endeavours. The relative success of these individual endeavours, in aggregate, in terms of productivity, and in relation to other countries, determines the real wealth of a country. Not borrowing.

I suspect that we are about to find which vision of economics is correct. I hope I am wrong. If I am not wrong, then the outcome may be very disturbing.

Friday, December 30, 2011

Krugman at it Again

I have just read an article by Paul Krugman, that yet again defends Keynesian economics. It would be amusing were it not taken seriously by so many. Let's take a look at the kick-off:

“The boom, not the slump, is the right time for austerity at the Treasury.” So declared John Maynard Keynes in 1937, even as F.D.R. was about to prove him right by trying to balance the budget too soon, sending the United States economy — which had been steadily recovering up to that point — into a severe recession. Slashing government spending in a depressed economy depresses the economy further; austerity should wait until a strong recovery is well under way.
One small detail, Professor Krugman. Keynes, unless I am mistaken, did not propose that deficits were also run during the 'good times', but that was the situation of many of the economies in the run up to the economic crisis. These deficits were not the only stimulus; there was the rapid expansion of credit in both the consumer and business spheres. I do not think that Keynes had in mind that growing government deficits were a good thing during the good times, and I very much doubt that his response to a debt bubble would be to continue the growth of the bubble, for example replacing growth in consumer debt with growth in government debt. Even if accepting Keynesian economics (which I do not), then this is nothing to do with Keynes, except in regards to ignoring his wider context.

Professor Krugman later argues that there was no real fiscal stimulus, due to state cuts in spending, and suggests that the stimulus was not enough. He then argues:

So the real test of Keynesian economics hasn’t come from the half-hearted efforts of the U.S. federal government to boost the economy, which were largely offset by cuts at the state and local levels. It has, instead, come from European nations like Greece and Ireland that had to impose savage fiscal austerity as a condition for receiving emergency loans — and have suffered Depression-level economic slumps, with real G.D.P. in both countries down by double digits.

So the US government is not borrowing and spending on a scale that can only be comparable to World War II? I mean really? What is happening is that the government is borrowing at record rates already. Is this not a massive government stimulus? Not to mention the massive stimulus of printing money, and ongoing targeting of record low interest rates. Also, he is comparing the current government borrowing with previous levels of borrowing in the good times, when there should have been no borrowing at all. In other words, the economy was already structured around servicing consumption of government borrowed money, even before the economic crisis struck.

As for the problems confronting Greece and Ireland, these are just the illustration of the problems of too high deficits. Nobody wants to lend them money. People operating in the bond markets simply doubt that they will ever get their money back if they invest in these countries. Krugman appears to address this argument (emphasis added):

Now, you could argue that Greece and Ireland had no choice about imposing austerity, or, at any rate, no choices other than defaulting on their debts and leaving the euro. But another lesson of 2011 was that America did and does have a choice; Washington may be obsessed with the deficit, but financial markets are, if anything, signaling that we should borrow more.
What Krugman is mistaking here is the fleeing of investors into the $US as a safe haven, as a winner in the 'least ugly' contest for money. However, his argument is investors want the US to borrow more! He ignores the fact that it is quite possible that the US might actually lose the least ugly contest if the US were to grow the rate of debt accumulation. He also ignores the fact that bond yields have been held down through money printing, and that any appreciation in US bond yields would see more money printing to keep the yields down. Just the promise of more money printing will, of itself, keep yields lower. He goes on to say that (again, my emphasis):
Again, this wasn’t supposed to happen. We entered 2011 amid dire warnings about a Greek-style debt crisis that would happen as soon as the Federal Reserve stopped buying bonds, or the rating agencies ended our triple-A status, or the superdupercommittee failed to reach a deal, or something. But the Fed ended its bond-purchase program in June; Standard & Poor’s downgraded America in August; the supercommittee deadlocked in November; and U.S. borrowing costs just kept falling. In fact, at this point, inflation-protected U.S. bonds pay negative interest: investors are willing to pay America to hold their money.
And if the Euro crisis was not taking place? Let's imagine a world in which there is financial stability, that sovereign debts in Europe are sustainable, that the Japanese economy is sound and so forth. If investors were to then look at the US, I think that there would be huge flight of capital. And this is the point; in the reality of today, where might the capital fly to? Yes, Professor Krugman, the US has managed to continue to accumulate debt without any major problems so far. It is not because purchasers of bonds want the US to issue more debt, but they simply cannot think of anything else to do with their money. If there were new measures that saw an increase in the rate of debt accumulation, it would simply test the status of the US in the least ugly competition. It is not a test that would be advisable.

Also, how much is enough borrowing, Professor Krugman? At present, the borrowing of the US government is at record levels. How much is needed, and for how long? What is the point at which the borrowing becomes counter-productive/unsustainable? Does it ever? At what point will taxes need to be raised to cover the borrowing? Or are you proposing that borrowing now will not mean high taxes later (in which case, the borrowing during the boom times should have led to a great boom now)? Where are all the answers to the basic questions?

It seems to me that simply saying borrow and spend more is fatuous argument. Yes, if you borrow and spend more, employment will increase (or decrease less), economic activity will increase, and the economy may even appear to grow if you borrow and spend enough. At the same time, the economy will structure around servicing that debt based consumption, entrenching the necessity of accumulating more debt. This is the history of Greece. The trouble is that, this only works as long as people are willing to fund the debt. The Greeks got away with it for a long time under the false premise that they were as sound as other members of the EU. Then it was apparent they were not. All that has happened since is that we can now see the real size of the Greek economy when debt accumulation slows down. Therefore, my final questions for Professor Krugman are; how big is the US economy when debt based consumption is removed? Or does he believe that debt based consumption is a productive part of the economy? Does he believe spending borrowed money creates real economic growth, or an illusion of growth that is dependent upon the ongoing accumulation of more debt?



Friday, November 13, 2009

Who Might Run Industrial Policy?

It has been a while since I have last written a post, and the choice of subject matter for this post has proven to be a difficult decision. On the one hand, there is the ongoing tremors in the financial system, and on the other there are the global shifts, such as the unsubstantiated suggestion by China that they may allow the RMB to appreciate. Added to this, there is the ongoing ascent of the gold price, as investors and governments move into the asset of last resort, and the progressive decline in value of the $US. This from the Wall Street Times:
"The gold market is kind of surprising here," as it holds on to the psychologically important $1,100 level, said Ralph Preston, senior market analyst with Heritage West Financial.

Watching the dollar's next moves will be crucial, Preston said. "It's going to be interesting whether the dollar is developing a bottoming formation or if it is about to fall off a technical cliff."

I will leave such matters alone for this post, as they are being covered elsewhere. Instead I would like to focus on one of the widely utilised government stimuli; the cash for clunkers schemes. I am focusing on this subject, as the scheme has appeared to give a temporary reprieve in the downwards trajectory of many economies. My inspiration was an article in the Telegraph, in which Jeremy Warner analyses the impact of the stimulus on the UK economy.

The purpose of my post is to highlight the absolute foolishness of such government measures in relation to arguments for more government interventions in economies. A long while ago, in a discussion of GDP measures, I pointed out that Hurricane Katrina would have seen an uptick in US GDP. The destruction of infrastructure, housing and other assets would have led to increased activity in the economy, as business and government sought to replace the assets that were lost. In other words, the destruction of a hurricane would appear to be a positive boon for an economy. On such logic, bombing your own cities would be good for the economy.

As it is, we have seen a natural disaster replaced with a man made disaster. Each of the cars that has been scrapped early is an asset with a real value, and useful life. Just as a bridge being destroyed in a hurricane still has a useful potential lifespan, the same might be said of the cars that have been scrapped. Quite simply, the result is just the same.

In some ways it is an identical process to running a production line with a garbage compactor at the end of the production line. As each unit comes off the production line, the compactor simply crushes the item. The result of such a measure would be that the demand for the item might never be met, and the production line would be kept endlessly busy. Output would be maintained, GDP figures would be positive, and the economy would apparently be doing well as the result of this ongoing activity.

What I am discussing is not particularly original, and many other commentators have made similar observations. On this occasion, I am reiterating the point due to comments on my previous post. One of the regular commentators, writing under the name of Lord Keynes, made a robust defence of government intervention in the economy, proposing that governments develop industrial policy. What followed was a heated debate about the relative merits of government interventions, with both sides of the debate arguing their points vigorously.

In light of this debate, the purpose of this post is very simple. I have outlined the principles of a government policy, adopted in many countries, which is just a process of destroying useful assets - governments destroying something and suggesting that this is good for the economy. These governments include the same people in whom Lord Keynes appears to profess so much faith. These masters of our economic destiny actually think that premature destruction of assets is good for an economy. These are people who would count Hurricane Katrina as having had a positive impact upon an economy. Few would say such a thing directly (though I do recall that the Economist magazine came close to actually saying it), but they would see the positive GDP growth from the activity from Katrina as a 'good thing'.

My question is very simple. How can anyone have faith in these people? It is extraordinary that anyone might have faith in people with such bizarre beliefs. Really, can we trust these people with the widespread interventions in the economy, as proposed by Lord Keynes? The very same people who instigated the cash for clunkers policy would be the same people who would devise 'industrial policy'. Lord Keynes is not alone in having such faith in government interventions, and the worry is that those with his views are gaining ground. The advocates of ever more interventions, ever more shift of resource into government hands, are becoming ever more plentiful. That such beliefs are gaining ground is a real cause for worry.

Sunday, January 18, 2009

Governments Should Panic - People are Saving Money

The inspiration for this post is the first article that grabbed by attention today, and it was a real attention grabber. For those who think that this blog is pessimistic, this is Peter Spencer, chief economic advisor to the Ernst & Young ITEM Club quoted in the Telegraph:
My concern is that people don't fully understand the dangers lurking out there. The Bank of England needs to move towards quantitative easing immediately – you don't have to wait until you get to zero per cent interest rates. If someone is choking to death you don't think twice about giving them an emergency tracheotomy. There may be dangers, yes, but the alternative is that they die.
These are indeed dramatic words. The interesting point here is that the ITEM club uses the same forecasting model as the UK treasury. As such, the government will be seeing the same flashing warning lights. I have visited the ITEM club website to get more detail on their report, but nothing has been published yet. However, there are several points that stick out in the article, and it is these that have grabbed my attention. In my last post, I was considering the problem with mainstream economics, and the report on the ITEM club thinking relates to this.

The following is apparently one of the great concerns for the ITEM club:
We are now in danger of seeing the economy choke: and once you get into a situation where people are hoarding as much cash as you can throw at them and interest rates are stuck at zero, you're in real, real trouble.
The reason why I looked for a report on their website was to try to clarify their concerns expressed here. It is not clear whether their concern is the interest rates or consumer spending, or a combination of the two.

However, I will proceed with my best interpretation. The interpretation I am using is that their concern arises that people are not spending despite interest rates offering no real return on their money. Bearing in mind that their concern is deflation, they seem to be imagining that people are 'hoarding' cash in the expectation that prices will drop further in the future. In making such a statement, I have a feeling that they are imagining the mythical 'homo economicus'. This is the idea that people will make rational economic decisions. Anyone who knows of people loaded up with consumer credit will know that this is indeed a mythical creature.

According to the ITEM club, what consumers apparently are doing is sitting on piles of cash so that they can buy things cheaper in the future. It appears that the man in the street is listening to the economists, and actively withholding their spending until prices fall.

However, this is to ignore another impact of the current economic position. Every day that goes by, there are more and more headlines of job losses and falling house prices. Might it not be more likely that consumers are not spending for the following reasons:
  1. Many will be scared. With mounting job losses, many people will fear for their jobs. Such fear is hardly likely to be an encouragement to spending...
  2. Even those in work who are reasonably confident will see that there are pay freezes, working hour reductions and so forth. In such an environment, in such a climate, many will know that their annual pay rise is likely to be modest. Their expectations of their likely future wealth will be dropping. Again, hardly an encouragement to consumer spending.
  3. House price falls. Many people saw the increase in the value of their homes as a safety cushion, offering a sense of security for their profligate spending. With the rapid disappearance of the safety blanket, they will not be inclined to spend so much....
  4. I think the ITEM club imagines a world in which, like themselves, everybody is on a salary such that, barring redundancy, their income is fixed. However, this is to ignore the many independent tradesman and self-employed, many of whom will actually see their income dropping, even though they may not be unemployed. People with falling incomes, and insecurity about where their next work will come from are hardly likely to be spending.
In general, I simply do not believe in Homo Economicus. However, I do believe that he can make an appearance when there is no other option.

In all of these cases that I have provided, a more rational approach to finances is being forced upon people through fear for their own individual prospects. I would suggest that, for the majority of individuals, saving to await price falls is an economist's fantasy. Last Christmas it was proposed that consumers held off spending until the last moment in a big game of 'chicken' with the retailers. Apparently, they held back from spending because collectively they were waiting for the retailers to drop prices in their desperation to get custom. I think there may be a very small element of truth in this, but would suggest that most consumers held off because of fear (for the reasons given above), and finally caved in because an emotional sense that they wanted a 'good Christmas'.

Christmas is also a good broader illustration of the irrationality of individuals. The UK is largely a secular society, such that Christmas have very little religious significance. As such the persistence of spending so much money on presents and the other rituals of Christmas is irrational. Every consumer knows that on Boxing Day, prices will tumble. Despite this, they spend large amounts of money just before they know that prices will see massive falls. Without a religious driver, this is nothing to do with rationality - but to do with sentiment and emotion.

This whole argument about consumers deferring their spending to make savings later is actually flying in the face of the history of the last ten to twenty years (at least). The boom in credit is the exact opposite of this deferral, as people have spent before having the money and therefore have purchased at greater cost.

However, this is the justification for many of the actions of government. The deflationary theory is built upon the premise that, if consumers have an expectation of falling prices, they will defer consumption. However, as the Christmas example, and the experience of the massive growth in consumer credit suggests, this is the exact opposite of the behaviour of many consumers. Whilst there may be a number of consumers out there who are so thoughtful and rational, it is impossible to argue with the fact that huge numbers of people have been buying on credit, and therefore consume on an irrational basis.

According to the deflationary theory, this consumer behaviour has magically flipped. Why would consumers suddenly get so wise?

The real explanation for deflation is the combination of actual shrinking incomes, and fear of shrinking incomes. This means that consumers do not have as much money to spend, or fear to spend what they have. As such, every provider of consumption goods or services must work harder to gain a share of the shrinking market, including offering discounts. Those that provide goods and services to consumers are also in a battle with rational fear, and seek to overcome that fear with the prospect of ever more attractive prices.

This is the cause of deflation. Rational fear and less money available for consumption. Whilst this will create a downward spiral, it is not a spiral driven by expectations of falling prices.

It is somewhat surprising how much assumption there is in a couple of paragraphs from the ITEM club, but there is an even greater and more contentious assumption. As I have already gone into such a lengthy discourse, I will re quote the second paragraph, which concerns the second point that I would like to make:
We are now in danger of seeing the economy choke: and once you get into a situation where people are hoarding as much cash as you can throw at them and interest rates are stuck at zero, you're in real, real trouble.
At this point, I will ask you to not read on for a moment. Before reading on, see if you can spot the emotive descriptors in the paragraph. Re-read the paragraph with this in mind, and I hope you will spot a most curious expression.

In case you did not get it, the key word here is 'hoarding'. Consumers are not 'saving' money, but instead are 'hoarding' money. Hoarding is what dragons, pirates and greedy kings do with gold. Hoarding is a 'bad thing'.

However, if we rephrase the paragraph as follows, then we see a very different picture:
We are now in danger of seeing the economy choke: and once you get into a situation where people are saving as much cash as you can throw at them and interest rates are stuck at zero, you're in real, real trouble.
What we are now seeing is an argument that says that saving is a bad thing and is the destruction of the economy. If people save 'you're in real, real trouble'. The solution to this real trouble that they are proposing is quantitative easing, or printing money.

In printing money, they will relight the fires of inflation, and that inflation will apparently get consumers spending again. However, such an assumption is built upon several other assumptions.

The first of these I have already detailed - the assumption that consumers are not spending because their minds have magically flipped such that, all of a sudden, they have learnt to defer spending so that they can achieve savings.

The second assumption that they make is that spending money today is better for the economy than saving money. This ignores the fact that savings are what provides the pool of new and genuine capital for businesses to utilise in order for them to expand and grow business (note: the process of central bank money creation does not provide this, but merely shifts value from one place to another). The banks have previously lent foolishly, thereby destroying their capital base, thereby creating a situation in which they need to repair their capital base, thereby meaning that there is a shortage of credit. In order for this position to be rectified, they actually need consumer deposits. That means they need consumers to save.

Furthermore, it is very puzzling that saving might be seen as a bad thing under any circumstances. Saving is rational consumer behaviour. If a consumer saves money, they will gain interest on those savings (except where the government sets an interest rate in which no return is possible), and will therefore increase their future purchasing power. This means that they will be able to buy more with their money than they otherwise would be able to buy. In addition, this feeds into benefits in the wider economy, as has already been pointed out, by making more capital available for investment. The greater the availability of capital for investment, the cheaper the cost of capital, and the greater the profits for business.

Is this not a virtuous circle? Investment of wealth into business creates jobs, which creates income for individuals, which creates wealth for consumption and further investment...

There are two problems at present with the switch to savings. One is that savings have been very low, such that consumers have to make up for their past lack of savings. The second problem is the flipside of this - that there has been too much debt driven consumption, and that debt driven consumption can only go so far before the weight of debt becomes unsustainable. There must come a point in time at which consumers will have to start paying down debt, and at that time, overall spending will have to decrease. In such a situation there must be a contraction in consumer activity, which means that economic activity must contract, which means that unemployment must rise, incomes are likely to drop (or at least not grow), and there will therefore be greater competition for less money, which will mean more competition on prices, which means deflationary pressures.

I say these are problems, but in reality the problems are arising due to previous problems, and are actually a necessary price for them. The contraction is necessary, but it will be painful. In this sense they are problems to live with (in that they will cause hardship) but are also a correction of (and solution to) the previous problems.

As a note I have discussed before about the counter-effect of a falling currency on prices, so will not detail this point again here. My focus here is primarily on the issue of savings and deflation, and the assumptions that underlie the ITEM club thinking, and the thinking of many mainstream economists.

The key points here are that the theory of the mechanism of deflation makes a basic assumption that is not supported by the recent behaviour of consumers, and it exactly the opposite of the way that they have behaved for a very long time. The second point is that there is an assumption that saving is a bad thing for an economy, and that consumption, at whatever cost, is a good thing.

In my last post, I pointed out how there was a fetish amongst many economists for activity. Activity, by their reckoning, in any form, is a good thing - even to the point where the economic activity resultant from the destruction of Hurricane Katrina is seen as positive economic activity.

Such fetishistic obsession with activity is at the heart of the ITEM club thinking. Their primary concern is to get consumers spending again, and if that means spending borrowed money, this is not important. The fact that spending borrowed money is unsustainable is not taken into account. In the past, the borrowing was funded to a large measure by overseas lending. Their solution, in the absence of the overseas capital is to print money to lend to individuals and businesses in the hope that this will generate activity. However, such money adds absolutely no value to the economy overall, it merely moves the value of the existing money onto the printed money (which moves to the government).

Such an action is therefore simply a tax on savings and investments, meaning that the amount of capital available for investment is diminished. Not only does it destroy the value of the savings that are in place, it also is aimed at encouraging people not to save, such that the recovery of the level of capital to allow for new investment will be restricted.

What we are looking at is a situation in which the purpose of the ITEM club policy is to create an environment in which they are seeking to overcome the rational fear of consumers by destroying the value of savings - to such an extent that it is simply not worth holding money. This destruction of the value of money will encourage consumers to spend money as soon as they get it, thereby encouraging consumption.

This sounds like massive inflation, does it not?

The views of the ITEM club are not unique. Their views are a mirror of the views of governments, with the main difference in their thinking being a sense of urgency to destroy incentives to save.

There are two puzzles in all of this. The first puzzle is how anyone can believe that people saving is a bad thing. Whilst it might see further economic contraction in the short term, it is necessary to create a foundation for future recovery. Any policy which is aimed at prevention of saving is a policy that is aimed at the 'now' but at the cost of the future. The second puzzle is why on earth economists think that consumers will defer spending for cheaper prices tommorrow, when the evidence points in the other direction and where there are far more plausible explanations for why consumers are not spending. Their theory of deflation is just very odd.

When we look at the two paragraphs from the ITEM club, we can see that there is a considerable amount of assumption in their thinking. However, those assumptions, when examined, are most curious and rather muddled. When we think of government policy, we must bear in mind that their thinking will be along the same lines, even to the extent that they are using the same models.

It is more than a little bit worrying.

Note1: I have re-read my post, and I am hoping that my explanation is clear and consistent. If not, please feel free to post comments and, time allowing, I will try to clarify the points.

Note 2: Lord Keynes has responded to my reply to his comment on my last post (that is rather a mouthfull - sorry). I will try to address the points made, but do not want to go further into what the 'right' level of expenditure on education might be which, as I will explain, is a diversion (to which I previously succumbed). I do think that Lord Keynes is missing the central point, which is that if x amount of spending on education was a bad thing yesterday, why is it a good thing today? Either it was wrong yesterday, or it is wrong today. I have perhaps not explained myself well enough, so will seek to clarify my thinking.

When Keynesianism comes out of the closet, it is quite astounding how much underinvestment is suddenly recognised. Seemingly, huge tracts of previous underfunding is discovered in coincidence with the 'need' for Keynesian spending schemes. It is also noteworthy that everyone has their own pet projects that have apparently been neglected, such as public transport, green energy, education and so forth. All of these projects become 'investments', but the curiosity is that they were not deemed good investments yesterday....

In other words, the Keynesian spending becomes the route for everyone to overturn previous spending restriction on what different individuals think is important. Every one of these projects can suddenly find justifications, but these justifications were not sufficient to win the argument yesterday, at a time when there was more finance available for the project. I could get into a similar debate for any one of the wide range of spending plans and meet exactly the same level of argument and justification for each of the plans. I could devote huge amounts of time on this blog in endless arguments about the relative benefits of every one of the projects being mooted for expenditure.

The point here is that it may, or may not be, correct that one individual project is a 'good thing', but it is an absolute certainty that much of the expenditure will not go to worthwhile activity. It can not be the case that all the previous restrictions on spending were wrong.

In particular, there is a point at which government spending just becomes a wasteful drain on the economy. Otherwise, government spending could rise perpetually with no negative impact upon the economy, and only positive impacts. It is possible to argue about that level, but if we accepted the level yesterday, why should be not it accept it today?

If we do not accept this principle, if we think that government expenditure could perpetually rise and benefit the economy, we would have to accept that the government that spent the most would have the most successful economy. This is not a case of reductio ad absurdum. Caps on government spending are there so that the expenditure of government does not (in principle) lead to wasteful expenditure. Keynesian economics is the removal of those caps. If something is deemed worthy of investment, meaning that it is believed to have potential for a return greater than the capital expenditure, then it would already be funded.

Such is politics that, even without the excuse of Keynesian economics, not all government spending is necessarily justifiable, though that is a wider issue than the additional spending than the argument over Keynesianism, and is beyond the scope here. What is at issue here is why previous thought on what was an acceptable level of expenditure can suddenly, as if by magic, be overturned.

At the heart of this is that I would argue that the more a government spends, the more likely it is to waste money, though some might argue that this is not the case. If a person believes that higher government spending = greater economic success, then their starting point and mine are a long way apart, and I would have to offer a very long discourse to put my case forward. It is beyond the scope of this reply to offer such a case.

Returning to Keynesianism, at a time when there is less finance available, to increase government spending is quite simply mad. In doing so, what were previously likely to be, at the very best, marginal benefits from expenditure suddenly become compelling arguments for expenditure. This simply does not make sense.

These now 'compelling' arguments come at the cost of either massive increases in government borrowing, or printing money. This is done for projects that were yesterday deemed as being at best of marginal worth....As I said, madness, as the spending now will mean less money for spending in the future on projects which are considered to have greater potential than marginal benefits. However, many of the projects that are now being funded would normally have been dismissed as a waste of money, but are still going to be funded. In spending on projects deemed to have questionable benefits now, there will be less money in the future for projects with more assured benefits.

The choice is very simple. Waste money now on projects whose benefits are questionable or with very little benefit, or do not waste money now and have more money for better projects in the future. Which is to be?


Note 2: I have had a very interesting comment from Pete Murphy on my last post, and strongly recommend that you read it. I have often had a vague notion that the US trend of building so called MacMansions (huge houses) was a driver of consumption. However, I never thought about it in the wider context of Pete's discussion. What he says intutively makes a lot of sense, though I am still contemplating his argument on free trade. If I have time, I will try to take a look at the book he has written on the subject (as a note for Pete, I do not consider mention of your own book on economics as being spam, though if you had linked to Amazon that would be different. Your comments and mention of your work are welcome).

Friday, January 16, 2009

Mainstream Economics (or why we are in deep trouble)

My apologies for the lack of post recently. It is not through lack of work on the blog, but rather that I now have two posts (one of which is very long and detailed) sitting in draft form but which I am not inclined to publish. They will probably be deleted after I finish this post.

One of the posts I hesitated to publish, as I have been worried that I am obsessing about China's role in the world economy, and the post was quite heavily centred towards China. In the second of the posts, I was taking an overview of the world economy, and was falling into the trap of obsessing about the details of national current account balances, external debts, and a whole host of figures. I even started to try to develop a standard way of looking at the prospects for different countries.

This kind of standardisation is the economist's trap, stopping using thought and replacing it with dogmatic theory and equations. I have noticed that the dismal science (the nickname for economics) has been coming under some fire of late, and I believe it deserves to be under attack.

With a few notable exceptions, the economists have completely failed to spot this catastrophe, and failed to even notice that the world labour force had doubled in the space of ten years (for new readers - this is one of the key themes of this blog, explained in context here). Perhaps the most worrying part is that, even though the crisis is now upon us, now that there are massive upheavals in the world economy, this 'little detail' of the doubling of the global work force has still not registered as a possible cause in the minds of economists.

I can not emphasise this enough - the world has just gone through what is possibly the greatest supply shock in history, and the entire economics profession has missed it. It is quite simply astonishing.

However, for a short time, as I was writing the second post, I fell into the same way of thinking as economists. I thought that I could create a formulaic way of understanding the positions of countries in the world economy relative to each other. Such an idea is, of course, impossible. Each country has too many individual characteristics, quirks, features and circumstances to be neatly slotted into an easy formula.

I was recently speaking with a friend, who is very interested in economics, and who asks difficult and challenging questions (which is a very good thing). He asked me to explain how it is that Germany with its social democratic system, encompassing many structural features abhorrent to free market economists, has such a successful export machine. I will confess that I was stumped to come up with an easy answer, and was left to waffle about German culture.

Now I have said that I was waffling about German culture, but this is to be unfair to myself. I have worked for a German company and have seen their business culture close up. I have also worked for a French company (in two joint ventures in China), a US company, and a British company. In all of these cases I was also working with companies internationally (they were all multinational companies), and have therefore worked indirectly with a very wide range of people of different nationalities - from Japanese, Spanish, Italian, Swedish, Australian through to Vietnamese and so forth.

What I can tell you with absolute certainty is that each culture brings with it certain strengths and weaknesses in business, and these strengths and weaknesses must impact upon the economic strength of their countries. It is, of course, difficult to generalise and encode such cultural strengths and weaknesses, so economists pretend that they are not there. However, such strengths and weaknesses do play out in the real world, and do have an impact.

As a simple example, if something goes wrong because one of your suppliers has let you down, a UK company might explain to their customer that the problem was that of their supplier. The Japanese company by contrast would be more likely to say that it is their problem, as they chose the supplier. In this case I am generalising based upon personal experience, and whether such experience can create a generalisation can be a matter of argument. It is not a firm fact, but a personal interpretation of experience. However, if the generalisation is broadly correct, it has profound implications for the way in which business operates in the UK and Japan, and this in turn has impacts upon the economy overall. Whether in this case I am right or wrong, it is impossible to deny the impact of such cultural factors - but this is just what economists do. There is a reality disconnect in the way they think about the world.

The point I am trying to make here is that economics is not about clever formulas, and complex equations, but is about who is the most competitive at providing goods and services. It is for good reason that marketing is sometimes called applied economics, because all economics finally comes down to the choices of individuals who are the final decision makers in a county's economic success or failure. At its most basic it is the question of 'do I buy product x from the Japanese, German or US company?' If, across an economy, lots of people are making choices to buy goods from, for example, Japanese companies, then the Japanese economy will likely prosper from such decisions.

It is within such decisions that economics really resides. The factors that determine such decisions are very complex at the level of the purchaser. However, if we look at each country, we will see that they will offer various strengths and weaknesses which will determine part of that purchase choice. In one case a country may have a costly government overhead that is reflected in the cost of operating a business, but companies might offset such costs with high productivity and/or a culture of innovation. In another case, it might be that government overhead is low and productivity is relatively low, but the conjunction of the two still offers a competitive advantage. The permutations are endless and each individual business may be different, each will respond to their broader environment in different ways, but overall there will be general strengths and weaknesses in each economy.

Such individual differences in economies make a difference, and can not be reduced to simple formulas. How can you provide a formula for a culture of innovation?

To give an idea of the complexity, some examples of factors that will determine success of an individual national economy are culture, law, taxation, regulation, type of education, levels of education, social stability, social support systems, size of internal market, availability of natural resources. This is just a selection from the top of my head, and a little further thought would produce any number of additional factors, some of which you might think are more or less important than those that have been listed.

The point here is that there is no formula for success, no secret 'Goldilocks' formula that is 'just right'. It is for this reason that mainstream economists struggle so much. They try to imagine a formulaic answers to economics, and forget that what finally drives economic success is the decision of a person purchasing a product or service finally drives the process from the bottom up. What finally drives such choices is not based upon a formula, but how the many factors impacting upon an individual business come together, and how that business works with those factors to advantage or disadvantage withing their particular market.

All of this is not to say that the big picture of economics is without merit, in other words that macro economics is without merit. Just as any economist uses the big picture numbers, so do I. However, regular readers will have noted, for example, that I have talked about the hard working culture of the Chinese in my discussions. In other words, whilst looking at the numbers, it is necessary to incorporate subjective judgements on top of the numbers. No equation can account for the many factors for success or failure in circumstances of so much complexity.

Not only is it necessary to combine the numbers with subjective judgements, but it is also necessary to think about what the numbers actually mean. Again, economists have got into a rut, and seem to accept numbers at their face value. It is such complacency that has made a fetish out of GDP figures. As I have pointed out (endlessly), the GDP figures that have been watched so closely have incorporated debt fuelled consumption multiplied into huge activity in the economy. Steady GDP growth in Western economies became a fetish, and everyone forgot to ask what the source of the activity might be. It was a dogmatic formula that stopped people from thinking. The formula was constant GDP growth = economy performing well. Quite simply, it was wrong, and is proven to be wrong. Activity built in debt fuelled consumption has to be paid for by less consumption activity in the future.

The problems of economic thought run far deeper than this however. I have been reading a lot of philosophy of science of late and, by accident, came across an academic paper discussing an absurd economic theory (1). The absurd theory in question approximates to a theory that drug addicts were making rational choices, and the author points out how completely absurd the theory is. I will not discuss the details of the argument regarding why this economic theory was absurd, but rather his conclusions about the way in which economic theory operates. He points to the absurdity of the models that they created, and how clever these models appeared to be. However, the models were all founded upon assumptions with no solid grounding whatsoever, and a little thought on their assumptions simply revealed that the economists were talking nonsense.

Such absurdity is currently all around us. For example, we see it in the policy of quantitative easing. Such discussions are always surrounded by dense economic theory, jargon and buzzwords. Even the expression quantitative easing does not express what it really means, which is a massive creation of money from nothing.

This is a policy in which there is a 'fetishisation' of economic activity, rather than productive economic activity. If there is not enough credit flowing through the economy, then government will make the credit out of thin air. At the heart of this thinking, if we really think about it, is the belief that wealth can be created, not through labour and innovation, but through government command. It is also the belief that if businesses are borrowing, consumers are borrowing, then the economy will be fine. The fact that printing money is merely redistributing the value of money does not seem to cross their minds, and it appears that they actually think they are actually creating money, rather than destroying the value of money. The fact that within the economies there is simply not enough real wealth creation to support this new money is completely absent from their thinking.

The same argument goes for the revival of Keynesian spending. I wish I could find the article to reference it here, but I read the most clear and concise description of why the Keynesian theory of government borrowing and spending is simply absurd. Essentially, under the theory, building something with absolutely no value is a good thing, as it increases economic activity. It is related to the theory that smashing a shop window is a good thing, as this also creates activity. Another article points out how prevalent window smashing view is, and how utterly silly it is. An example in the article quotes several reputable sources who proposed that the bright side of Hurricane Katrina was that it would create a boost to economic growth - through creating a stimulus for activity in the economy. After all, the massive damage meant that there would be a need for lots of new construction and so forth.....

These are the ideas that are prevalent in mainstream economics. Such thinking would see an economy in which we would build a new skyscraper, knock it down the day after it was built, in order to build it again. The fact that nobody might want to live in, or hire office space in the skyscraper is irrelevant, as it will create economic activity. Economic activity is 'good' for the economy.

Of course, when it is presented to the public, it is never presented in these terms. It is investment in infrastructure, or couched in terms of economic stimulus and so forth. However, it was investment, then it would be done anyway. It would have a reasonable probability that it would produce a return on the capital, and therefore would attract the capital. As for the idea that it is a 'stimulus', yes it is a 'stimulus'. However, the idea that a stimulus can only be good is a fundamentally absurd idea. If a person gives me an ice cream this is a stimulus, but if a person gives me an electric shock this is also a stimulus. I think that the former is good and the latter is very bad indeed.

In the case of all government stimuli, the money for the stimuli does not come from the government, but in all cases comes from the tax payer. It is either taken from the tax payer in the form of inflation or through direct taxation. The taxpayer's money is then used to do the equivalent of building a skyscraper which no one wants. How can this be a good thing? Would it not be better that the tax payers use that money for something that they actually want? Would it not be better that the money was available for saving, which means that it is available for investment, and can then be used for investment in something that produces things that people actually want? Nobody wants the skyscraper. Why on earth build it? It is literally flushing all of that labour and material down the drain. It moves resources into quite literally pointless activity.

These are the answers governments to the economic crisis. Making money out of thin air, and redirecting the capital of nations into completely pointless activity.

To add insult to injury, they are also pouring money into bankrupt banks. They are literally pouring money into black holes resultant from bad / irresponsible lending and investment. Today comes news of a massive additional bailout of Bank of America of $US 138 billion. This is not money from the government but, one way or another, is money provided by every tax payer in the US. The difference here is that, instead of using that tax payer money to build a useless sky scraper that no one wants, they are simply destroying the value of money, as the funding for such activity will inevitably end up being achieved through money creation and inflation. Will this actually result in any new wealth creation, will that money ever lead to real productive activity?

The answer is that this is not even in the discussion. It is simply beyond mainstream economists to ask this question - as all they are seeking is activity in an economy. They want to stimulate lending and credit, and do not care how it is done because, as long as people are spending, then all is fine. Spending is activity, and activity in an economy means a good economy. After all, GDP growth is 'good' and GDP growth measures activity.....

Such a view can only be described as delusional, and it is the recognition of this delusion that started this blog (with my essay 'A funny View of Wealth').

As a blogger, I freely confess that I am not a trained economist. I have simply looked at the world around me, and have found that many of the ideas of mainstream economists are simply absurd (which is reflected in the 'I just don't buy it....do you?' in the title of the blog). I have been a regular reader of the Economist, have read Adam Smith, and have an economics textbook as a reference. The only use I have for the textbook is in understanding the jargon of economics, so that I can understand the underlying principles of what is being discussed. Beyond that, the book is largely useless. As a technical explanation of the current economic structure it is fine, but as an explanation of the underlying economic world it is hopeless.

Since I started writing this blog, I have relied largely upon the observation of the real world and critical thought to get me through. None of what I have considered has been rooted in theory x or theory y. However, as I have written the blog, I have been increasingly exposed to different paradigms of economic thought, and ever greater depth of discussion of economic theory. What I have found is that there are voices in the world of economics that are also expressing their concern, that there are several others who also 'do not buy it' (e.g. the Austrian School of Economics). However, these voices are are ignored by governments and, as a result, Keynesian thinking has been alive and well in government (in various modified forms), for a very long time.

This mainstream thinking has been with us for a very long time, and has led to economies - such as the UK and US - being left in a terribly vulnerable state. I can not emphasise enough that it is a paradigm that can produce some of the most absurd thinking. It is a world in which Hurricane Katrina's after effects would recorded as an upwards blip in GDP growth, a world in which this 'growth' would be recorded as a positive thing. It is a world in which havoc and destruction can become a 'good thing'. If you want to understand the underlying principles of the economic mainstream, just keep this in mind. Hurricane Katrina = increased activity = GDP growth = good economy.

I have noted that many people who link to this blog, whilst positive about what is said, also give warning that it does not make pleasant reading, that it is a 'doom' blog. When we think that those who are deciding our economic destiny, people who think that the idea of building a sky scraper before knocking it down again might be a good idea, that creating money out of nothing is good, that Hurricane Katrina is good for the US economy, how can this blog be anything other than pessimistic?

Note Added Same Day: I have already had a couple of comments on this post and, at risk of messing up the RSS feed, will publish a reply. One comment goes to the heart of the problem with Keynesian spending.

The comment comes from Stever Tierney (see comment below), a regular and well informed commentator on the blog. Steve's comment was of great interest, as he has offered up the fairly standard answers for why a Keynesian boost is a good thing (this is not being rude, but an observation that you have understood the arguments). I recommend that you read Steve's comment before reading on.

The first point is this. Steve says the following:
'If the government uses the money to build a school, thats not something nobody wants. .'
If the school was something that really was of such value, why was the school not built before? It is a very peculiar idea that, at the very time you are most short of cash, that you start finding a mass of projects that, at the time that you did have cash, were not of great enough importance to spend money on. Is this coincidence? Last year, we did not need the school, this year we do need it. This year it is an investment, but last year it would have been a waste of money. It all seems very convenient that all of these 'good' projects have suddenly appeared as good projects, and are suddenly no longer a waste of money. A bad project yesterday, but a good one today.....

It really does not make any sense at all. A project is either worthwhile or not worthwhile, and unless there is a huge coincidence, nearly all of these projects were deemed a waste of money (or they would have been undertaken) - right up until someone opened the government floodgates of spending. I really don't buy it....

...and please, do not anyone suggest that the project would always have been done if the money had been available.....

If a project is an 'investment' it will create a return. A government can (normally) borrow extremely cheaply, such that even a very small return on the investment would be justification. As such the money is always there, it is just that the spending can not be justified in any way that looks reasonable or coherent.

As such I will continue on an assumption that this is spending that has no underlying need.

In the case of building the school, there is more that can be said. If the school is being built as a replacement for a school that is already there, the old school will cease to be a school. In this case, we are back to knocking down sky scrapers so we can build a new one (I know that it might be possible to sell the old building, but the principle is there, as the new building is almost certainly going to cost much more than the old, or the new school would have been build already if it was necessary/desirable).

On the other hand, if we are going to build an additional school, then we are back in the situation of building the sky scraper that nobody wants to live in. Even worse, in the case of a school, it is an additional cost, and provides no income. At least with a half full sky scraper there is some possibility of some income to offset the costs of maintaining the building. In this case, not only is the building surplus to needs, but it will probably be an ongoing drain on the finances. In other words it will add costs but with very little benefit - it will just make the education system that bit more inefficient.

There are several other examples given by Steve, and I will leave you to work them out yourselves. There is, however, another argument put forward by Steve, and it concurs with the general points made by defenders of the current proposals for the Keynesian spending spree. I will quote Steve again:
Bridges and schools and roads and the like do have to be built. If the government 'moves the building forward' that was going to be done sooner or later anyway so as to keep people in jobs and prevent normally-viable businesses closing down that is not necessarily the wrong thing to do.
This is the 'moving the building forward' argument. It might be summarised as, we were going to spend the money anyway, so why not just bring it forward. However, as these proposals are put forward, you will note there is a silence on the question of the future. Do we hear that there will be binding cuts on future expenditure on infrastructure? Do we actually believe that, in two years time, the money spent on the project today that was planned for two years time will actually be taken off the future infrastructure budgets? Do we really believe that, as these projects are moved forward, we will see a commensurate shrinking of future budgets. If a project is bought forwards 2 years, then in two years time will we see the same amount removed from the budget in 2 years, that a project bought forward three year will see the same amount removed from the budget in 3 years, and so on...

I think to believe that this will be the case is simply unrealistic. Furthermore, if the government were to do so, then the economy would simply contract by the amount of the expenditure now as a cut in the future. In this case, what has been gained? However, regarding the idea that they would cut the budget, I simply do not believe it. As such all of this so called 'bringing forward' is really just additional spending, and therefore falls under the 'building sky scrapers that nobody wants' argument.

Finally, steve gives the following argument:
After all, those still-employed people will otherwise be claiming benefits, defaulting on their mortgages etc.
Yes, people will otherwise claim benefits, but there is a significant difference in the cost of employing people to build infrastructure that is not needed, and the cost of benefits. The former solution is very, very much more expensive. Such an argument only makes sense if the projects on which these people are employed can be justified on their own merits. However, as I hope I have demonstrated, these projects are the equivalent of my original sky scraper argument. They are pointless projects.

As for saving individuals from defaulting on mortgages, this is the same as just paying their mortgages directly. Is this really a solution? Why not cut out all of the costs of concrete, earth movers, and the other costs associated with building infrastructure, and just have the government pay mortgages. When it is put this way, suddenly (I would imagine) it becomes less attractive as a solution.

As much as the government tries to bury it, spending is just spending, and it is not investment. Furthermore the spending is paid for out of taxes. The amount of wealth that the economy creates/has stored is fixed at any moment in time. What is happening when Keynesian spending takes place is that the government spends a greater proportion of that actual wealth at the expense of the taxpayers.

I must make this 100% clear. There is no new wealth, just a redistribution of wealth.

If people pay more tax, they have less money with which to consume and save. If they have less money with which to consume, there will be a commensurate decline in the situation of those companies that support such consumption. If they have less to save, their will be a commensurate decline in the accumulation of capital available for investments.

Added to this, if the government is borrowing to pay for the spending, then they are borrowing from a finite base of capital, thereby acting as a competitor for capital with private business. as such, the government borrows at the expense of private business borrowing. Furthermore, in the future, the government will have to increase taxation to pay for the borrowing, thereby creating a contraction in the economy in the future.

If governments pay for the spending through printing money, they are paying for the spending through the indirect taxation of money. As fast as they print the money, they are taxing every investments, every item of expenditure, through the transfer of wealth from the existing money supply onto the new money (you can not give money value through printing it, it must take the value from the existing money supply). In such a situation, the amount of money printed will match the value taken from the existing money supply so that, as fast as you are printing the money, you are removing exactly that amount from the existing money as a form of tax.

As I have said, there is no new wealth added in Keynesian spending, just a transfer of money from individuals to the government.

An then we think what the government is doing with that money.....

If we think of what that same money might do in the hands of individuals, or as savings available for investment in private enterprise....

A quick note: Lemming has mentioned that productive activity is an idea that is difficult to pin down. I can understand the point Lemming makes in his comments, and sympathise with the views. However, it is not up to us to decide what others value in their lives. For example, if they are foolish enough to buy an over-priced car, that is their own foolish choice. I am not sure how or why we should interfere with such choices.

Note Added Same Day:

I have had no less than three comments from a commentator, Lord Keynes. Perhaps as a result of his name he is offering a defence of Keynesian approaches. I think that he must have been writing his comment as I was writing my reply to Steve Tierney, so I will not address the 1st comment (unless he believes I have not addressed it). However, I will address the other two posts.

In the first of the two, he says the following:
(1) For example, we see it in the policy of quantitative easing … Even the expression quantitative easing does not express what it really means, which is a massive creation of money from nothing.

(2) In the case of all government stimuli, the money for the stimuli does not come from the government, but in all cases comes from the tax payer. It is either taken from the tax payer in the form of inflation or through direct taxation.

Does not statement (2) contradict statement (1)?
He is quite right, that this is a contradiction. On the one hand, governments treat it as if they are making money by magic, but the reality is that there is actually no real money created, just 'funny money'. I perhaps should have been more precise. When I mean I say creation of money from nothing, I should specify that that this is delusional perception. I am very clear that there is a transfer of value from the existing money supply, so I think I have made this clear elsewhere. I should make the distinction between what mainstream economists think, and what actually happens.

With regards to the second point, I am not sure I am clear on the point being made. Can you clarify your question? The ability of central banks to create money is not, I believe, a matter of great contention. The matter of contention is whether they should be able to do so, or how much money they should be able to create under what circumstances (for those that accept the principle). Of course, the terms in which money creation is discussed is never explicit, but that is another matter...

On the subject of Keynesian spending, Lord Keynes says the following regarding the school example, and presents a new argument:
Because schools are nearly always built with public money, and there has been a persistent trend since 1979 (the advent of neo-liberalism) in Western countries to cut public spending. Education was one of the many things to suffer.
This is an argument that is one in which it is now suggested that the spending now is being used to make up for past failures to spend. In this we start hitting one of the problems not with Keynesian theory, but with the way that is being applied. In simplistic terms, the idea is that governments should pay down deficits during the 'good times'. However, this has not been done, and the suggestion here is that not only has this not been done, but expenditure on infrastructure has also been neglected. As such there has been deficits and neglect of the infrastructure.

Does this not say something about the terrible underlying state of the economy?

As it is, the UK government share of UK GDP has risen, and the US GDP share has fluctuated somewhat, but not changed dramatically. In absolute terms in both cases the spending by governments have increased. As such, whilst it might be claimed that education budgets have been cut, this chart here actually shows the growth in educational spending in the US. What we have is actually greater spending, and yet we have claims that the infrastructure has suffered...now the answer is to spend yet more to fix problems that occurred as a result of lack of enough spending in the good times, times in which spending increased.

The question this raises is: how much is enough, and if we can afford this spending in the 'good times' how can it be afforded now, or paid for in the future? Is it not the case that we just have to accept that there is not enough wealth creation to afford such spending?

Another point to make is that, if economic success is a result of good education, what level of spending should be directed at education. 5% of GDP, 2%, 10%? If it is such a basic good, then why not just pour in huge amounts of money? In reality we accept that there must be an optimum level of spending, before the money is wasted. Once again, if investment is increased in education today, when yesterday the money spent on education was considered to be at the right level, does this not say that the money is believed to be inefficiently allocated.

The answer in response will be; better that a person gets an education than sitting on benefits, but again there is the problem that yesterday it was not expected that the individual in question would benefit from further education, but today that person will increase their value in the workplace through education. If this is the case, why were they not encouraged into education before? They would have increased their value in the work place, gained a better salary and so forth. The economy would have benefited from better value from their input and so forth...As for building infrastructure, educating people is an expensive business. That means more tax, less consumption, and less money saved for investment (again).

With regards to the necessity for government funding of schooling, I would point to my post on education reform. My solution offers cost effective schooling in which individuals have freedom of choice, and a system focused on quality of outcomes. The system is one in which education becomes a real investment, in that the investment will be set at a level at which realistic expectations of returns on the investment are central. By contrast, government is pouring more money into the system with arguably ever poorer outcomes, and no way of measuring the so called 'investment'. It is quite simply, drop x amount of money in and hope for the best...

Lord Keynes also says of education:
'I would also add that there is more to educating children than just making them useful workers, but that’s an argument for another day.'
There are a large number of creative industries, people who make money writing history books and so forth. In addition, at least in the UK, for many jobs the exact subject of a degree is not considered a matter of concern. A system that allows for investment and returns still allows for breadth of education, rather than simply training for work. There is no reason to believe that such degrees will not continue to be funded if return on investment is a consideration.

The final argument is a continuation of the first comment as follows:
I would continue to ask why something like the Hoover dam, the construction of which has had many benefits, is a “bridge to nowhere” project? In none of your discussions, do you address the fact that governments do try and calculate the economic benefits of much public infrastructure spending (the US actually is inefficient because of Congressional control and pork barreling, something other government systems, for instance in Europe, do not have)
The question is, if it is going to make money, why would government finance be needed. A recent example of such a kind of project is the Channel Tunnel. This was privately funded and added a major piece of infrastructure. It has lost money, but nevertheless, it is still there, and still provides that infrastructure. A similar point can be made for the railway system in the UK, the massive boom in telecoms infrastructure.

On the other hand, it is also possible to look at Macquarie group, who have been making massive investments in infrastructure around the world (though I personally have some doubts about their business model), and making good profits. Some of these investments provide returns, some have been loss making, but the risk is not given to a public who have no choice through the tax system, but to investors willing to take the risks.

The trouble is, if the government is borrowing money, there is not so much capital available for such private investment. If you have the choice of what has appeared to be a low risk government bond, or a relatively high risk investment in an infrastructure project, you will go for the bond, unless the infrastructure project offers very big returns. In competition with this, you have governments raising money cheaply on the basis that if it goes wrong, which is a common occurance on infrastructure, then the taxpayers will foot the bill. How can private capital compete on such terms? It is a very difficult task, but they do still manage to compete.

It is the Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac story writ large. They came to dominate the mortgage market, as they were implicitly underwritten by the tax payer and could therefore raise finance cheaper. It made any true competition in prime mortgages virtually impossible.

So we can talk about the benefits of infrastructure, but the question is to ask why this has to be provided at risk to tax payer money, and at the cost of crowding private investment out of the market.
Furthermore, public works programs often simply maintain and repair crucial existing public infrastructure. The US, by all accounts, has crumbling public infrastructure simply because governments have not spent enough money to maintain them. Now is the perfect time to rebuild them.
So again, we have a situation in which these expenditures were not considered affordable during the 'good times' but are affordable now that there is no money? Does this make sense? You are broke, so you spend money on things that you did not think were worthwhile when you were rich? According to this argument (to paraphrase another person's argument), you should work on refitting your kitchen at home when you are made redundant, even if you have to borrow the money to pay for the materials. It needs to be done, as it is looking run down, you have nothing else to do with your labour, so why not?

The why not is because you are already in debt, can not pay down that debt, and are hovering on the edge of bankruptcy. Even without debt, would this be a good idea? Would you recommend such a course of action to your friend? Heh, you may as well do something useful with your time, even if it puts you into debt with no idea of when or how you might pay it back.

In the end, it is all just a continuation of the delusions. A continuations of the belief that, when a problem has been caused by debt, the solution is more debt....It is the fetish that activity means wealth, and if we can just stimulate enough activity, consume enough, it will all come right. The fact that the stimulus is built on debt and devaluation of money, is a small detail that passes many by.....

A long and a rushed response as I have spent a bit too much time on the blog, so I hope that it answers the questions.


(1) Rogeberg, O (2004), Taking absurd theories seriously: Economics and the case of rational addiction theories, Philosophy of Science, 71, pp. 263-285

Note 1: The post on China that I did not publish was an explanation of why I obsess with China, as well as why I personally would like to see China succeed. As such it was a little too personal for publication.

Note 2: I was asked some time ago to write an article for a finance magazine, and am hoping that it will be published in the near future. I will link to this as soon as it is out.

Monday, July 7, 2008

The Multiplier Effect

I have had a couple of responses to my post 'Government Waste an example...' by two anonymous posters (hereafter 'anonymous1' and 'anonymous2').

The first post I will respond to is provided by Anonymous1, who discusses the multiplier effect, citing Wikipedia (i). The principle of the multiplier effect is explained in Wikipedia as a company building a factory, and how the money then circulates through the economy through, for example, the employment of builders. It is pointed out (correctly) that this will raise output overall in the economy.

Anonymous1 links this idea of the multiplier effect to my article about government waste, asking the following question:

'Can there ever be value in economic activity for its own sake?'

Anonymous1 also (again correctly) links this to the economics of Keynes, who believed that government ameliorate the effects of recession/depression through increased government spending (relying in part on the multiplier effect).

I have talked about the multiplier effect in my essay 'A Funny View of Wealth' (See my posts June 2008, though I do not use the term itself), and point to this effect in the creation of the recent boom. In this case the stimulus was a massive inflow of money in various forms of consumer debt and government debt.

Now to return to the question asked by Anonymous. Can there be value in the kind of economic activity for its own sake (i.e. of the kind that I detailed in my post on government waste). The first point is that, even if we accept the idea of using government spending to ameliorate the effects of recession/depression is a good thing, this kind of spending could not be justified, as it was undertaken during a period of economic boom. It would therefore be an additional stimulus to an already highly stimulated economy (in this case stimulated by growth in consumer/government debt). As such, this kind of spending, regardless of questions of economic philosophy, was just plain wasteful. All of the members of the team on the project almost certainly could have found more productive employment in other sectors of the economy. As such non-productive activity was displacing potential productive activity. Furthermore, the source of finance was from, at least in part, genuinely productive sectors of the economy. For example, it is possible to make a relatively crude argument that some of the finance used to fund the activity might otherwise been used to expand a productive business. Instead it was taken as taxation.

Another point made by Anonymous was as follows:

'And when you consider that the 'real' economy apparently thrives on jobs like mobile phone ringtone development and crystal healing he might have a point. Presumably the jobs people do in the 'real' economy are justified because others are prepared to pay for them, but by any definition, many of them are pointless and wasteful.'

I would not actually say that these jobs are wasteful, as the people who buy such services value them. Whilst they are (by my view) odd ways for people to spend money, they have as much value as a bottle of whisky, or going to see an opera. How people spend their disposable income is not an issue in the overall picture of economic health, excepting the issue of whether the spending retains wealth in the country (whether the purchase is for imported goods or services). What is an issue is whether there is a sustainable source of productive activity that creates sufficient output to allow such discretionary expenditure to take place. There are many ways that such output can be created, and I consider these in some depth in 'A Funny view of Wealth'. However, the idea that such wealth can be sustained through the expansion of borrowing is not included, and my argument is that borrowing has been the source of the UK's apparent (illusory) wealth.

What I am saying is that we can say that crystal healing, however odd it may be, is productive output as long as someone values this service. If the service is provided to the wife of a Russian oligarch, then this odd activity even provides a net contribution to the UK economy as a whole. If it is paid for by a factory worker out of his/her wages, it represents a distribution of the wealth created by the worker's productive activity. If it paid for out of debt accumulation, it becomes a net loss of future wealth for an individual. In all cases the service remains a productive activity in its own right. The real problem lies in the origin of the wealth that is redistributed through the purchase of the service. If we return to the multiplier effect, the question is as to where the wealth is coming from - its real origin. Is it from the loss of future wealth represented from debt, or is it from productive activity? In each individual case, it is nearly impossible to separate out the origin of the wealth that is redistributed. This is why we can have an illusion of economic growth, when the reality is that the economy is becoming poorer - through the loss of future wealth represented by debt accumulation.

The real problem arises when a stimulus is created through debt accumulation, and individuals and government believe this is real wealth creation, rather than loss of future wealth.

I hope the above answers the question posed. Next, a slightly more difficult post provided by Anonymous2.

Anonymous2 points to the difficulty in seeing the reality of the waste for anyone outside of the system, and says:

'Your post suggests that an awful lot of public sector employment is wasteful. I have heard people use the term 'rentier economy' to describe the UK. One characteristic of such a state is a high level of unproductive public sector employment designed to keep much of the population content.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rentier_capitalism
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rentier_state

The thing I don't understand is what the resource is that we would be 'renting out' externally.'

I will do my best to answer some of your comments, though I am not sure I fully understand your intent.

What we are doing in the UK, in many cases, is selling assets such as utilities to non-UK owners, which offers a short term boost of cash in the economy.This is at the cost of these assets becoming a source of 'rent' for the new owners of the assets. As such, whilst such sales of these assets present a short term cash boost for the economy, over the long term they represent a net loss of wealth. After all, if a person buys an asset, their intention is to extract more wealth from the asset than they have invested into the asset. This process comes under the term inward investment, and inward investment is widely seen as a 'good thing'. However, (sorry to mention it again) as is discussed in my essay 'A funny View of Wealth', it is not easy thing to determine which kind of inward investment represents an overall gain for the economy, and which represents a loss. I mention the case of the utilities as an example, because this is an example where it is hard to find any sensible reason for why there might be a gain for the economy. For other inward investments, such as establishing a manufacturing facility, the relative benefits are harder to measure (sorry, but for this discussion to make sense you really need to see 'A funny view of wealth', where I discuss the potential pros and cons in depth). However, it is certain that certain kinds of inward investment will over the long term see a net loss for the UK economy. Some of these investments might plausibly support elements of what Anonymous1 is suggesting (if I have correctly understood the meaning of the comment).

This government, and previous governments, have enjoyed the short term benefits of such (ongoing) sales of assets which helped provide an illusion of a healthy economy. How this works is a complex subject, and is difficult to summarise. A simplistic analogy is to think of a company that has owns a piece of productive machinery. It then sells the machine to a finance company that subsequently leases it back to the company. This gives a short term benefit to the balance sheet of the company, but has the long term negative effect of having to pay back more than the initial short term cash from the sale. It looks good on paper initially but, in the end, the company will have spent money with no productive gain (unless the money from the sale is invested in something else that generates more cash than the cost of servicing the lease).

As for the suggestion that the government is using spending to maintain a content (docile?) population, this is a very cynical view, but does have some merit. The more people that are dependent on government income, the more likely they are to vote for a government, and support a government that promises to continue with the spending. This is all very well, but creates a long term structural problem in the economy due to government spending removing people from productive activity. The government pays for this unproductive activity through taxation of productive activity. In doing so, the government sets in train a process of long term economic decline. The really tragic part is that this creates potential for a vicious circle, where a government will need to create ever more 'make work' jobs in order to retain votes and power. As the productive economy suffers under the burden of wealth extraction, it starts to contract, and the government responds by making further extractions to maintain the economy to a degree where the voters will still continue to vote for the government and, in doing so, makes more people dependent on the government, and so on.

I am simplifying, but I hope that you take the point. This government has seen a marked increases in the numbers of civil servants, as can be seen in the following article:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1457104/%27Day-of-the-long-knives%27-for-50%2C000-jobs-in-the-Civil-Service.html

This is a very old article, so the figures are now very much out of date (sorry, I am a bit pushed for time, but it serves to illustrate the point).

In addition, there are many other areas of government spending where there are jobs reliant on government spending and in reality the workers are state employees, but which are not directly recorded as such (e.g. the project that I worked on). Every one of these jobs creates a dependency on continued government spending at a cost to the productive parts of the economy.

The implication in the comment by Anonymous2 is that this dependency is planned. In this respect, I disagree with Anonymous2. I think that there are people out there who genuinely believe that the kind of wastefulness, as I detailed in my original post, is actually of value to the economy, and genuinely believe that an ever expanding state can be maintained alongside a healthy economy. As such, where I would agree that such expansion creates docility in a large part of the electorate, I do not believe that this is part of grand plan. I would accept that there is tactical usage of such government expenditure, but do not (perhaps wrongly) believe that there is any strategic plan. Perhaps I am naive but I think that, even allowing for the petty ambition that drives politics at the micro level, the majority of politicians (and the government) are unaware that the cumulative negative effect that such micro-level activity can create. Each little piece of expansion has its own justification and appears, on the face of it, to be merited.

Note for Anonymous2: I am not sure that I have answered your point fully. If you read my this post and feel that I have not addressed your points, then please feel free to post a follow on, and I will do my best to respond.


(i) There are some people who very critical of Wikipedia, pointing out inaccuracies in various entries. However, an independent study comparing Wikipedia with Encyclopaedia Britannica found that there were less errors on average in Wikipedia. I compared the Wikipedia definition with one in an economics textbook, and concluded that the Wikipedia definition was more intelligible. My experience with Wikipedia is almost all positive. The link given for the citation was:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiplier_effect